9-21-2017: Court rules use of Stingray to track people without a without a warrant violates 4th Amendment

Article #1:

EnGadget, “Court rules Stingray use without a warrant violates Fourth Amendment” by Mallory Locklear


      Today, the Washington DC Court of Appeals overturned a Superior Court conviction of a man who was located by police using a cell-site simulator, or Stingray, CBS News reports. The court ruled that the defendant’s Fourth Amendment rights were violated when law enforcement tracked down the suspect using his own cell phone without a warrant.

      Stingrays work by pretending to be a cell tower and once they’re brought close enough to a particular phone, that phone pings a signal off of them. The Stingray then grabs onto that signal and allows whoever’s using it to locate the phone in question. These sorts of devices are used by a number of different agencies including the FBIICE, the IRS as well as policeofficers.

      The use of cell-site simulators, especially without a warrant, has come under question a few times in recent years. In 2016, a federal judge suppressed DEA evidence obtained via such a device, the first time a federal judge had done so. Last year, members of Congress called for legislation that would protect citizens’ privacy and require a warrant before Stingrays could be used by law enforcement. Two such bills were introduced in the House of Representatives earlier this year.

      In the ruling, the judges said, “We thus conclude that under ordinary circumstances, the use of a cell-site simulator to locate a person through his or her cellphone invades the person’s actual, legitimate, and reasonable expectation of privacy in his or her location information and is a search.” They also said, “We agree with [the defendant] that the government violated the Fourth Amendment when it deployed the cell-site simulator against him without first obtaining a warrant based on probable cause.”

     The ruling could affect ongoing and future cases as well as law enforcement’s use of the technology.


Back to Cases in Progress

Were You At Standing Rock?  Write Your Testimony.

Order Your State’s Discovery – upon request, the state is required to provide to you all evidence they gathered against you.

Order Your Court Transcripts

Full Archive

Archives by Category

Home Page


Thank You for Standing!

Would you like to Help Spread the Word about www.StandingRockClassAction.org?

     Feel free to print out these cards on quality cardstock paper & hand them out:

StandingRockClassAction 10 cards PDF


Special thanks to Think-AboutIt. com for the above graphic we’re utilizing in accordance with Fair Use.


This website is being compiled by Wild Willpower.

Our Fundraiser on CrowdPAC

Connect on Facebook

Special thanks to www.NoDAPLarchive.com for all your hard work helping to compile the initial archive.

Creating Clarity from Chaos